Ecological training in Brazilian Jiujitsu, one of the latest buzzwords in the ever evolving world of grappling. If you haven't heard of it, congratulations on either being blissfully ignorant or just too busy choking people out the traditional way.
For the uninitiated, ecological training (ET) is an approach that prioritises live, game-based learning over traditional drilling. Instead of hammering out 500 perfect arm bars in a row like some kind of psychotic grappling robot, ET focuses on learning through problem-solving in real-time situations. Basically, it’s like throwing a toddler into a swimming pool and assuming they’ll figure it out before drowning. Sounds great, right?
Well, yes and no. Let’s take a deep dive into the pros and cons of this training method, and why....brace yourselves....it might not be all sunshine and omoplatas for white and blue belts.
The Pros of Ecological Training
1. It Mimics Real Fighting Situations
If you’ve ever had an opponent politely ask you to pause mid-roll so they can properly execute the technique they drilled last week, you’re either dreaming or rolling with a very confused yoga instructor. BJJ is chaos. ET embraces that chaos by making training sessions unpredictable, just like a real roll, or a drunken brawl at a kebab shop at 2 AM.
2. Develops Problem-Solving Skills
Rather than being spoon-fed a move like a toddler getting their daily dose of mashed bananas, ET forces you to think on your feet. You have to adapt, adjust, and troubleshoot in real time—something that, funnily enough, is quite useful in an actual roll. It’s the difference between memorising a recipe and learning how to cook with whatever is in your fridge. (Spoiler: one of those skills will actually keep you alive.)
3. More Engaging Than Endless Drilling
Let’s be honest, traditional drilling can sometimes feel like detention with extra sweat. “Do this move 500 times,” they say, as you contemplate faking a knee injury just to escape the monotony. ET, on the other hand, is more dynamic, allowing for faster learning while keeping things interesting. Who knew jiujitsu could be fun instead of just painfully repetitive?
4. Better at Building Instincts
Instead of waiting for your instructor to give you the green light to move, ET allows you to develop natural reactions. You learn to feel the weight shifts, anticipate movement, and react accordingly like a well trained jungle cat. Or at least, that’s the idea. Some of you will just end up flailing wildly, but hey, that’s part of the process.
The Cons of Ecological Training
1. Good Luck If You’re a Beginner
Here’s the thing, ET assumes that you have at least some clue about what’s happening. For higher belts, it’s an absolute game changer. But if you’re a fresh white belt, your ability to ‘problem-solve’ is about as effective as a goldfish trying to do algebra. You don’t know what a guard pass is, let alone how to adjust when someone tries to steamroll through it. For beginners, ET often feels like getting thrown into the deep end with nothing but a pair of armbands and a panicked expression.
2. Less Technical Precision
There’s something to be said for drilling the absolute hell out of a move until it’s second nature. ET can sometimes lead to a “close enough” mentality, where movements become sloppy and efficiency goes out the window. Sure, you’ll ‘figure it out,’ but wouldn’t it be better if you actually knew how to do the thing correctly in the first place?
3. Injuries Can Pile Up
When people don’t know what they’re doing, bad things happen. Ask any coach who has witnessed two white belts go full primal mode in a scramble, it’s like watching two untrained chimpanzees fighting over a banana. If you remove structured drilling too early in someone’s journey, expect more popped elbows, neck cranks, and regrettable life choices.
4. Not All Instructors Know How to Teach It
ET isn’t just about saying, “Go play, kids!” and hoping for the best. It requires structured game-based learning, carefully designed scenarios, and guidance that allows students to self-correct. Unfortunately, some instructors treat it like a free-for-all, which quickly turns into a mess where the only lesson learned is, “I have no idea what I’m doing.”
Who Actually Benefits from Ecological Training?
Now, let’s address the elephant in the room, ET is amazing if you’re an experienced grappler. If you’ve been training long enough to have a solid technical foundation, this method will take your BJJ to the next level. You’ll develop quicker reactions, better adaptability, and a deeper understanding of your own game.
But if you’re a white belt, it’s like trying to learn a language by jumping into a debate competition before knowing basic vocabulary. You don’t even know what a triangle choke is, and yet you’re expected to “discover” it like some kind of BJJ Christopher Columbus? Give me a break.
The best approach? Blend both methods. Newbies need structure, reps, and technical guidance before they can start improvising. High belts, on the other hand, should absolutely embrace ET to refine their skills and problem-solving abilities. It’s not an either-or situation, it’s about knowing when to apply what.
Final Thoughts: Is Ecological Training Worth It?
Yes! No! Maybe! It depends! (How’s that for a definitive answer?)
If you’re a purple belt or above, throw yourself into it, ET will make your game tighter, sharper, and more fluid. If you’re a white or blue belt, pump the brakes. Learn the basics first before you start ‘figuring things out’ in real-time. Otherwise, you’ll just end up reinforcing bad habits and wondering why nothing is working.
So next time you hear someone preaching about ecological training like it’s the gospel of BJJ, ask them who it’s actually for. If they say “everyone,” politely smile, nod, and then continue drilling your arm bar like a responsible grappler. Your future self will thank you.
Now go train and for the love of Helio, stop trying to ‘discover’ moves that were perfected decades ago.
Adz
Opmerkingen